My American League Gold Glove Winners

ESPN will be televising the Gold Glove Award show tonight at 10pm EST. I think it is a cool way to present an award but only if the award had, you know, good nominees.

The problem with the Gold Glove Award in recent years is that they have been awarded to horrible defenders who have faired well on offense. Sadly, an award that is meant to be awarded to the players with the best glove usually goes to someone who is a big name or put up good offensive numbers. It’s tragic.

I prefer The Fielding Bible Awards to the Gold Glove Awards because they actually look at the defense and have a panel of people who care about who wins the award.

With that said, here is who I would vote for at each position to win a American League Gold Glove Awards:

Note: I did not include pitchers because I do not believe the metrics are enough for me to conclude a solid choice.

(more…)

Matt Wieters’ Star is Brightening

When Matt Wieters was drafted out of Georgia Tech everyone saw an offensive monster that just happened to be pretty good behind the plate but may be too big to stay there long term. Three years and 1209 plate appearances into his career the opposite has been true and many out there beileve his star is fading. I believe his star is just starting to shine.

His career stat line of .267/.328/.401, while very good for a catcher, was not what everyone was expecting from the bat Wieters was swinging. On the flip-side, in almost 2500 innings behind the plate he has only 5 passed balls (Jarrod Saltalamacchia has 12 this season alone), has a +8.0 UZR, and has thrown out 32.1% of those who have tried to steal against him. Many ignore the success behind the plate because they either do not want to look at non-Sportscenter numbers or they are so focused on the offense that they forget there are two sided to the playing field. This season has been Wieters’ most promising both behind the plate and at the plate.

Behind the plate he has thrown out 45.5% of those who have tried to steal on him and he has not a single passed ball against him. I am not one to harp on errors but the fact that he only has two speaks volumes. If the season ended today he would more than likely win the Fielding Bible Award for catchers and an American League Gold Glove.

At the plate he is also having his best year hitting .269/.329/.425 with a .331 wOBA and 106 wRC+. His base running has improved each year, going from -4.3 Bsr to -2.4 Bsr to -0.2 Bsr this year. He has also been hot of late. Since June 24th he has hit .300/.372/.543 with 5 doubles and 4 homeruns and an 8:10 BB/K rate in 78 plate appearances. Only one catcher in the AL has a higher fWAR than Wieters’ +2.6 and it’s Alex Avila at +2.7.

Some have already labeled Wieters a bust. Others have relegated him to a regular but not a star. I always held hope that this young catcher would evolve into the star we saw at Georgia Tech and I believe we may be witnessing the evolution of what could be the best overall catcher in the game very soon.

-Jonathan C. Mitchell can be found writing about the Tampa Bay Rays at DRaysBay and you can follow him on twitter at @FigureFilbert and follow MLBdirt at @MLBdirt

My AL All-Star Starting Lineup

My NL All-Star lineup was posted yesterday and here is my American League starting lineup.

Catcher: Alex Avila has really jumped onto the scene this year and he is my pick for catcher. His AL Leading 2.6 WAR amongst catchers is 0.8 wins higher than the second place Matt Wieters.Avila has an impressive triple-slash line of .304/.375/.542 and the highest wOBA (.394) and ISO (.238) amongstAL catchers. He also has a very solid 10 homeruns and 45 RBI.

First Base: Many believed this guy to be a strong candidate for the AL MVP at the beginning of the year and he is not disappointing. Adrian Gonzalez has posted a terrific 4.5 WAR which ranks second in the entire American League and is 1.2 wins higher than the second best first baseman. He has a major league leading .361 AVG which is .020 points higher than the second best. He has a .415 OBP, .611 SLG, 16 homeruns, and a major league leading 71 RBI to go with.

Second Base: This pick was very close for me, between Ben Zobrist, Dustin Pedroia, and Howie Kendrick but I am going with Kendrick on this one. While Zobrist leads all American League second baseman in WAR (4.0), Kendrick is only 0.4 wins behind. Kendrick has the highest AVG (.304), wOBA (.373), and wRC+ (138) amongstAL second baseman and the second highest OBP (.362) and SLG (.479) His triple-slash line is better across the board compared to Zobrist.

Third Base: This was an easy pick for me as Alex Rodriguez is performing very well this season. He has a 4.0 WAR which leads the majors amongst third baseman and is 1.4 wins higher than the second best. He has a triple-slash line of .304/.382/.515 and a wOBA of .393.He has an ISO of .211 and 13 homeruns and I think he is a clear-cut choice to be the American League starting third baseman.

Shortstop: This pick could go a few different ways as there are a good three or four guys deserving of the start but for me, Asdrubal Cabrera has the slight edge and is myAL starting shortstop. Cabrera leadsAL shortstops in WAR (3.0), hits (93), homeruns (13) and tied for first in RBI (46). He has an impressive triple-slash line of .292/.342/.495 and he has also provided good speed on the base baths with 12 stolen bases.

Left Field: While he is not a true left fielder, Jacoby Ellsbury is my starting left fielder as he has been one of the best outfielders in the American League this year. Ellsbury has a 3.5 WAR which ranks 4th amongstAL outfielders. He has shown a great combination of speed and power as he has 9 homeruns and 25 stolen bases which leads the entire major leagues. He has a triple-slash line of .299/.361/.455 and has provided great fielding as well.

Center Field: Curtis Granderson has really bounced back this year and I am giving him the nod in center field for the American League. He has a 4.2 WAR which ranks first amongstAL center fielders and is third in the entire American League. He has shown great power as he has 21 homeruns, a .301 ISO, and a .579 SLG which all leadAL center fielders. His .405 wOBA is the highest amongstAL centerfielders and he has a very solid 13 stolen bases as well.

Right Field: Jose Bautista could easily be the first half MVP and it’s not even a competition on choosing him as theAL starting right fielder. He leads the majors in WAR (5.2), wOBA (.475), ISO (.336), OBP (.469), SLG (.664), and homeruns (24). He is having a monster season.

Designated Hitter: David Ortiz has easily been the best DH and he has also been one of the better players in general. He has a 2.6 WAR which leads all designated hitters. He has a great triple-slash line of .311/.391/.581 as well as a very good .419 wOBA. His 17 homeruns and .270 ISO also leads all designated hitters.

Starting Pitcher: This was probably one of my hardest picks as I was deciding between Jered Weaver and Justin Verlander but my final choice is Weaver. He leads allAL starting pitchers in WAR with 3.9. He has the lowest ERA in all of baseball (1.97) and the lowest FIP (2.46) in the American League. He is second in theAL in IP (123.1) and has given up the second fewest number of homeruns (5). While Verlander is very deserving of starting the All-Star game for theAL as well, I think Weaver has the very slight edge.

Catching on as All-Stars

I am continuing to fill out my entire American League and National League All-Star rosters. I recently announced my AL and NL starting rosters and I will continue to reveal my reserves but from here on out I will do them by position. I have already selected Brian McCann and Alex Avila as my starters so here are my two reserves for each roster:

National League

Miguel Montero (ARI) - He is quietly having another phenomenal season. He is hitting .2767/.348/.472 with 9 homeruns and a wOBA of .357. He also leads all catchers in base running with +1.9 Bsr. He ranks 2nd in the NL among catchers in fWAR (2.4) and 1st in doubles (21) and extra-base hits (30).

Chris Iannetta (COL) – He leads all NL players with at least 200 plate appearances in BB% with an astounding 19.7% rate. Next on the list is Joey Votto at 17.2%. Sure, his .224 AVG may be low but he leads all NL catchers with a .384 OBP and .219 ISO, and ranks 2nd in homeruns (10), wOBA (.366) and wRC+ (123). He also ranks 3rd in fWAR (2.1).

American League 

Matt Wieters (BAL) – Wieters’ stat line may not overwhelm anyone at .262/.315/.405 but he has thrown out 20 of the 48 potential base stealers this year. Not surprisingly he leads all catchers with +3.0 UZR and has been a key reason for the success of the Baltimore pitching staff. He has also shown some pop with 13 doubles and 7 homeruns and has been worth +1.8 fWAR.

Victor Martinez (DET) – This may be cheating a bit since he has only played 21 games at catcher and allowed 21 stolen bases in his time behind the plate but he is hitting a ridiculous .336/.383/.494 with a wOBA of .379 and has 20 doubles and 6 homeruns. If you claim he does not qualify then I would have to go with…I actually don’t care if you don’t think he qualifies. If I am picking my All-Star team, and that’s exactly what I am doing, then I am taking V-Mart as my third catcher.

-Jonathan C. Mitchell can be found writing about the Tampa Bay Rays at DRaysBay and you can follow him on twitter at @FigureFilbert and follow MLBdirt at @MLBdirt

My 2011 AL All-Star Starting Lineup

Now, it is time for the American League starting ballot:

CatcherAlex Avila (DET) – This is an easy call. His +2.7 fWAR  is almost a full win above Matt Wieters who ranks second among AL catchers. Avila is hitting .303/.373/.545 and leads all AL catchers with a wOBA of .395 and wRC+ of 151. His ISO of .242 also leads catchers. The only “catcher” with a higher average and on-base percentage is teammate Victor Martinez.

First Base: Adrian Gonzalez (BOS) – A deep position but an easy choice. Gonzalez could be the first-half MVP with his stat line of .361/.415/.611 and wOBA of .439 and wRC+ of 178. Among first basemen he ranks 1st in each of those categories except OBP where he ranks 2nd. He also leads all first baseman, by a large margin, in UZR with +7.4. Oh, and his 4.6 fWAR is tied for 2nd best in the Majors and just 0.1 behind the league leader.

Second Base: Ben Zobrist (TB) – Another deep position but this probably will not be a selection you see on most ballots but it is warranted. Zobrist is tied for 4th in the AL with +3.7 fWAR but he is tied with second baseman Dustin Pedroia. I profiled Zobrist over at DRaysBay and named him current team MVP. He is tied for the league lead in doubles (25) with Adrian Gonzalez, ranks 2nd among second basemen in homeruns (9), wRC+ (133), and ISO (.206), 1st in baserunning (+2.7) and extra-base hits (38), and is 3rd in SLUG (.474) and tied with Pedroia for 3rd in wOBA (.363). I give the nod to Zobrist for being the best 5-tool talent among a selection of deserving second basemen.

Third Base: Alex Rodriguez (NYY) – He is tops among third basemen and tied with Zobrist and Pedroia for 4th highest fWAR with +3.7 and is almost a full win ahead of Kevin Youkilis who is 2nd. He leads all third basemen in wRC+ (146), AVGe, and SLUG, and has a stat line of .300/.3778/.513. Much to my surprise, his UZR was a ridiculous +6.9.

ShortstopJhonny Peralta (DET) – Another close call here between Asdrubal CabreraAlexei Ramirez, and Peralta. Ramirez has the highest fWAR (2.8) but Peralta and Cabrera are right there with him (2.7). Ramirez is the better fielder and base runner among the three with Cabrera being the worst fielder (-5.0 UZR) and Peralta being the worst base runner (-1.7). But I chose Peralta because he was a +1.4 in the field and leads all shortstops in triple-slash categories, hitting .308/.358/.524 and leads in wOBA (.378) and wRC+ (139). His 12 homeruns ties him with Cabrera for the lead but Peralta has done it in almost 70 less plate appearances. This was a close race and I wouldn’t be upset if any of the three were named on a ballot.

Left FieldMatt Joyce (TB) – Another close call. Jacoby Ellsbury is hitting .303/.365/.461 with a wOBA of .370, wRC+ of 131 and ranks 3rd among AL outfielders (4th if you count Zobrist) in fWAR with +3.1 and leads them all with 25 stolen bases. Joyce has him beat in all triple-slash categories (.310/.373/.533), wOBA (.387), wRC+ (149), and base running (+1.5). Joyce’s 2.5 fWAR might be below Ellsbury’s but Joyce has him beat in every category except stolen bases and UZR (+1.5 to +0.5).

Center Field: Curtis Granderson (NYY) – He ranks 2nd among outfielders with +4.0 fWAR and is tied for 2nd overall with 21 homeruns. He has been good in the field (+1.3 UZR) and on the bases (+1.8 Bsr). He is also only one of two AL outfielders to have a wOBA of .400. He easily belongs here.

Right Field: Jose Bautista (TOR) – He is the current Major League leader in fWAR (4.7), homeruns (23), wOBA (.472), wRC+ (205), OBP (.468), SLUG (.655), and he’s hitting .325 and is a +2.3 base runner. Need I say more?

Designated Hitter: David Ortiz (BOS) – I find it ridiculous that we actually vote for a DH, especially when there is not one to vote for in the National League but Ortiz may have made the team even if there was no DH voting. He is hitting .311/.391/.581 and leads all DHs in wOBA (.419) and wRC+ (.165). His 17 homeruns are almost double the next closest DH and his 2.6 fWAR is almost a full win ahead of the 2nd place DH. Easy call here.

Starting Pitcher: Justin Verlander (DET) – This is yet another one that I struggled with. Jered Weaver leads the league in fWAR (4.0) and FIP (2.46), and is 2nd in ERA (1.97) and innings pitched (123.1) and is highly deserving to be the starter and I may be wrong in naming Verlander the starter but Verlander leads the league in innings pitched (128.2) and strikeouts (124), places 2nd in fWAR (3.6) and xFIP (2.94), 3rd in K/BB (4.59), and 4th in ERA (2.36), FIP (2.83), and K/9 (8.67). The deciding factor to me was the teams they faced. Verlander had to face the two best offensive teams, New York and Boston, twice while Weaver only faced them once and Weaver has faced Oakland, Seattle, and Minnesota, a/k/a the three worst offensive teams, more than Verlander has.

-Jonathan C. Mitchell can be found writing about the Tampa Bay Rays at DRaysBay and you can follow him on twitter at @FigureFilbert and follow MLBdirt at @MLBdirt

Who Will Represent Oakland in the All-Star Game?

This is a weird team to try and find an All-Star on. Injuries and a horrible offense have plagued this team all year. The highest fWAR player on the team is injured starting pitcher Brandon McCarthy who only has nine starts on the season. His 2.0 fWAR is almost double the highest offensive player’s total and 0.6 higher than the next closest player. One could easily argue that the “one player per team” rule is ridiculous and, while they would probably be right, Oakland would most likely be left without a player on the American League All-Star team this year.

Gio Gonzalez leads all non-injured Athletics with 1.4 fWAR. He currently sits with a 2.69 ERA and 3.62 FIP in 87 innings pitched. His 8.48 K/9 ranks 6th among all AL starters but his 4.34 BB/9 are second worst in the AL. The two things Gio has going for him are that the Athletics have to have a representative at the game and that the AL roster will need a left-hander that can get a strikeout late in the game.

Trevor Cahill was well on his way to not only making the All-Star roster but competing for the AL Cy Young Award. He has cooled down considerably and currently sits at 1.2 fWAR with a 3.24 ERA and 3.97 FIP in 100 innings pitched. He is 3rd in the AL among starting pitchers with a 55.5% ground ball rate and has a decent 6.67 K/9 but, like Gio, he walks too many guys with a 3.78 BB/9 which is 5th worst in the AL.

Another option is to pull someone from the bullpen, which has been a bright spot for this club. Brad Ziegler leads the bullpen with 0.6 fWAR and has a 1.93 ERA and 1.97 FIP and gets 66.7% ground balls but only has 23.1 innings. I would rather see Grant Balfour get the nod with his 9.48 K/9 and 2.59 EAR in 31.1 innings.

Kurt Suzuki is the leading offensive candidate. He leads the team in fWAR with 1.1 and as a catcher you might be able to justify finding him a spot on the All-Star roster but the AL already has Russell Martin winning a spot due to voting and Alex Avila might be the most deserving catcher. Carlos Santana and Matt Wieters deserve to be on the team ahead of Suzuki as well. Suzuki may not be the best choice based on stats but he may the only candidate to represent this team.

If I had to pick today I would probably go with Gio Gonzalez. I am not big on having more than 3-4 relievers on the All-Star roster and Gio has, so far, had the best season among those who have worn an Athletics jersey and can still throw a ball 60 feet 6 inches.

-Jonathan C. Mitchell can be found writing about the Tampa Bay Rays at DRaysBay and you can follow him on twitter at @FigureFilbert and follow MLBdirt at @MLBdirt

Random Predictions – AL

Who doesn’t love predictions? I know I do. I love mocking people for their outrageous claims but even more, I love making outrageous claims… and ending up right about them. Will my predictions be right? Only time will tell, but they do factor into my drafting and reaching of fantasy players. Some predictions will be bolder than others, especially my prediction in tomorrow’s post that says… well, you’ll have to wait for that one.

Here is my list of players that I predict bold outcomes for:

Baltimore Orioles – Matt Wieters will hit better than .280/.350/.450 with 20 homers. Adam Jones will go 25/10 or better. Mark Reynolds will hit below .200 again. Brian Matusz will pitch 210+ innings of sub-3.50 ERA, with 175+ strikeouts.

Boston Red Sox – Adrian Gonzalez will set career highs in Home Runs, RBI, runs, AVG/OBP/SLG, and win the MVP. Carl Crawford will be even better offensive season than he had in 2010. Daniel Bard will save 15 or more games. Daisuke Matsuzaka will not be starting games for the Red Sox in by August.

Chicago White Sox – Big league pitchers will stop throwing strikes to Alexei Ramirez and he will still swing and post an OBP that barely cracks .300. Adam Dunn will set a career high in home runs. Jake Peavy will make 25 or more starts and post an ERA below 3.75 with a K/9 over 8.0.

Cleveland Indians – Carlos Santana will be the best offensive catcher in the majors, hitting .290/.390/.470 or better with more than 20 homers. Shin-Soo Choo will be a top 5 MVP candidate. No other position player will be worth 3.0 fWAR or more and Orlando Cabrera will be off the team by the end of July.

Detroit Tigers – Ramon Santiago will be more valuable than Jhonny PeraltaAustin Jackson will take a minor step back before breaking out in 2012 and will be outperformed offensively by Casper WellsRyan Raburn will do like everyone else is predicting and break out this year. Detroit pitchers will be infuriated with the defense on the right-side of the field.

Los Angeles Angels – Vernon Wells will revert back to his 2009 form when he hit .260/.311/.400. Peter Bourjos is currently owned in 3.3% of ESPN leagues and will be owned in over 70% of fantasy leagues by mid-year, finishing with 40+ steals and 10+ homers. Dan Haren will be the best pitcher on the team.

Kansas City Royals – Melky Cabrera will again contend for the worst player in the Majors award. Alex Gordon will hit 25+ homers and post an OBP above .350. No starting pitcher will be worth 2.5 fWAR or higher. Tim Collins will have 75+ strikeouts out of the pen with a sub-3 ERA.

Minnesota Twins – Nick Blackburn will again post a +5 ERA but still start 25+ games. Alexi Casilla will struggle to post a positive fWAR. Delmon Young will break the 3.0 fWAR barrier, improving on last year’s performance. Jim Thome will again hit 25 homers and we will wonder why, again, he did not get 400+ plate appearances.

New York Yankees – Derek Jeter will have a bounce back season and hit at least .295/.365/.435 with 15 homers. Freddy Garcia will post a +5 ERA and not make it to 25 starts. Andruw Jones will hit 20+ homers and be worth 2.5 fWAR or higher. Jorge Posada will hit 15 or less homers and be worth 2.0 fWAR or less.

Seattle Mariners – I’m tired of seeing everyone predict Ichiro to bottom out this year. Ichiro will reach 200 hits, hit ovr .320 with 10+ homers and 40+ stolen bases. Miguel Olivo will fail to reach double-digit homers for the first time since 2005. Michael Pineda will be the 2nd most valuable starting pitcher. Brandon League will save 20+ games.

Tampa Bay Rays – Ben Zobrist will bounce backSean Rodriguez will gain shortstop eligibility and be a top 10 shortstop with at least 15 homers and 15 steals. Manny Ramirez hits .300/.400/.500 with 20+ homers. Dan Johnson will struggle to reach 400 PAs and the Rays will wish they signed Russell Branyan (his bold prediction tomorrow). Jeremy Hellickson will win 15 games with a sub-3.50 ERA and a K/BB of 4.0 or better. No pitcher will have 20 saves. It will be a true committee. For more of my Rays predictions click here.

Texas Rangers - Mike Napoli will retain catcher eligibility for next year and hit 30+ homers this year. Nelson Cruz will finish 3rd in MVP voting and hit at least .300/.370/.570 with 35+ homers with 25+ stolen bases and 10+ UZR. Elvis Andrus will hit 1 homer and fall outside the top-10 among fantasy shortstops. Derek Holland will win 12+ games and strike out 150+ with an ERA sub-4.00.

Toronto Blue Jays – The Jays 4th and 5th rotation spots will combine for an ERA over 5.00. Travis Snider will hit 25+ homers and post a +3.0 fWAR. Brett Cecil will be the best pitcher on the team. Aaron Hill will hit 30 homers.

-Jonathan C. Mitchell can be found writing about the Tampa Bay Rays at his other site Figure Filbert and on twitter at @FigureFilbert

NL/AL Most Improved Lineups

After off-season moves this past season, two teams come to the forefront, in my mind, on who became the most improved in the two different leagues.

(July 19, 2009 – Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images North America)

In the American League, the Baltimore Orioles made a meandering of changes in their lineup this off-season to try to support their young and talented pitching staff. The major off-season acquisitions included Derrek Lee, Mark Reynolds, J.J. Hardy, and Vladimir Guerrero. All four of those players have the power to hit 20 home runs, maybe with the exception of Hardy. He did however hit over 20 in the ’07 and ’08 seasons. The only problem in going this route, you’re not planning for the future. None of these four players will be with the team for more than a couple of years at most.

The interesting aspect what these players bring is the protection that Nick Markakis, Adam Jones and Luke Scott gain in the line up. Lee doesn’t have the same power he once had after his wrist injury, but is still a dangerous hitter. Reynolds will probably continue to strike out at an alarming rate, but will probably still hit 35+ home runs in hitter friendly Camden Yards. He also has to deal with the better pitching in the AL East compared to the much weaker NL West, which could be a problem. Junk ball hitting specialist, Guerrero should be a dangerous hitter in this line up as well. He’s thrived in the DH role with Texas last season, and I expect him to keep the same momentum going. If you figure in a healthy Brian Roberts at the top of the lineup, and a young Matt Wieters behind the plate, it could rival any team in the AL as one of the best lineups.

With the young pitching staff, the team is going to have to put up a lot of runs in order to help these young guys “take their lumps” while they gain more experience. Brian Matusz is poised to have a break out year, and Jeremy Guthrie could have a winning record with his normal ERA in the low fours or high threes. Between young pitchers Chris Tillman, Jake Arrieta and to an extent Brad Bergesen, with veteran Justin Duchscherer could make for an adaquete rotation with a very high ceiling. I’m not expecting a Cy Young winner to emerge from the group, but they could win a number of games with amount of runs the line up could mash in.

Potential Lineup:

Brian Roberts – 2B
Adam Jones – CF
Luke Scott – LF
Vladimir Gurrero – DH
Nick Markakis – RF
Derrek Lee – 1B
Mark Reynolds – 3B
Matt Wieters – C
J.J. Hardy – SS

It’s pretty hard to place all those power hitters in the lineup while trying to make the most sense. This will give coach Buck Showalter the flexibility to have a lot different lineup configurations depending on the pitching match up.  The only hitter on the team that hit over 20 home runs last season was Luke Scott. He should be poised to do the same, and drive in plenty of runs himself. This lineup might be one of the most balanced lineups I’ve ever seen as well. You have two switch hitters, five right handed hitters, and two left handed hitters. Fact of the matter is, they’re also in one of the best divisions in all of baseball. Between the Yankees, Red Sox, Rays and even the Blue Jays, I just don’t foresee them making the playoffs, but they’re going to surprise a lot of people this season. Will they make it out of the cellar? There’s a really good possibility that occurs.

On the NL side of things, the Washington Nationals added some players that give slugger Ryan Zimmerman some extra protection that could even take him up to a next level (if there is one for him). The additions of Jayson Werth and Adam Laroche will add 40-50 home runs from those two batters alone. Werth of  course was the super-star contract acquisition this season, but it’s going to be hard for him to live up to those expectations. Don’t get me wrong, he’s a fantastic player, and knew he was good with the Dodogers; he just needed that change to get regular playing time. He got that with the Phillies and got him a World Series ring in the process.

(August 5, 2009 – Photo by Doug Pensinger/Getty Images North America)

Outfielder Michael Morse appears to have gotten a shot to be the everyday left fielder for the team to start the season. In only 266 ABs, he hit 15 home runs and batted in 41. Assuming enough at-bats for an everyday player through out the season, 30 home runs and 90 RBIs aren’t out of the question for him.

None of the options the team has for center field are all that attractive. I think Nyjer Morgan makes the most sense to me, since he can lead off, so I want to assume they’ll go that route. Last I read; however, Rick Ankiel has the inside track to securing the position, which I’m not sure that is the best option for the team. Without Morgan, they have no true lead off hitter. Roger Bernadina is also in the mix for OF time. Ian Desmond is more suited to be the second batter in the lineup behind Morgan.

Youngster Danny Espinosa, who has 15 home run power is slated to take over duties at 2nd base. Desmond should able to build on a pretty decent rookie campaign from last season. Hot shot catching prospect, Wilson Ramos, who was acquired in the Matt Capps trade with the Twins could start to figure in the lineup too with aging Pudge Rodriquez. It’s also possible that Jesus Flores could factor into the catching spot too, but there has been some interest with him going to Houston when Jason Castro was lost for the season.

Potential Lineup  (How I would construct it):

Nyjer Morgan – CF
Ian Desmond – SS
Ryan Zimmerman – 3B
Jayson Werth – RF
Michael Morse – LF
Adam LaRoche – 1B
Pudge Rodriguez / Wilson Ramos – C
Danny Espinosa – 2B
Pitchers Spot

The pitcher’s spot brings up a really good point: The Washington Nationals rotation and bullpen are a giant mess. Livan Hernandez is _NOT_who you want pitching for you opening day. With Steven Strasburg on the shelf all season, and Jordan Zimmerman having his own injuries last season, the team doesn’t have much to work with. The other three pitchers poised to make the rotation are Jason Marquis, John Lannan and Tom Gorzelanny. They will not be able to compete at all with the Phillies, but could give the Braves and Marlins a kind of “run for their money”. They’re a much better hitting team this season, by spending a lot of money, but with out pitching they don’t stand a chance.

Young closer Drew Storen has seemed to lost his spot at closer as well with a horrid spring with an ERA over 11. I saw last that the team has no official closer announced as of yet. We’ll see what happens there. Tyler Clippard could get some time shutting down games of Storen officially loses it.

2011 Fantasy Rankings – Catchers

Carlos Santana

When it comes to catchers the concern for me is when to take them. Do you take the top catcher on your board early? Do you join the catcher-run when it starts? All tough situations that you can ponder but really cannot answer until the opportunity stares you down. I believe there is decent depth at catcher this year, especially if you are in a 10-team mixed league but be warned, there are few that can help in more than 3-4 categories.

With that, here are my rankings for catcher:

Rank Player Tier
1 Joe Mauer 1
2 Carlos Santana 1
3 Buster Posey 1
4 Brian McCann 1
5 Victor Martinez 1
6 Mike Napoli 2
7 Geovanny Soto 2
8 Miguel Montero 2
9 Matt Wieters 2
10 Kurt Suzuki 3
11 Jorge Posada 3
12 Chris Iannetta 3
13 Yadier Molina 4
14 J.P. Arencibia 4
15 Carlos Ruiz 4
16 John Buck 4
17 John Jaso 4
18 Jarrod Saltalamacchia 4
19 Ryan Doumit 4
20 Hank Conger 5
21 Chris Snyder 5
22 A.J. Pierzynski 5
23 Alex Avila 5
24 Russell Martin 5
25 Jesus Montero 5
26 Ramon Hernandez 5
27 Nick Hundley 5
28 Josh Thole 5
29 Wilson Ramos 5
30 Jonathan Lucroy 5
31 Tyler Flowers 6
32 Miguel Olivo 6
33 Jason Castro 6
34 Ryan Hanigan 6
35 Yorvit Torrealba 6

 

Three I’d Reach For Reason
Carlos Santana With all due respect to Mauer, Santana could be the #1 catcher by the end of the season. His power and On-Base Skills are huge, especially my main league.
Mike Napoli Love the park, love the power, love the lineup, love the potential.
Chris Iannetta He will probably hit below .250 but he walks and has power. Oh, and he plays in Colorado and should finally get the bulk of at-bats at catcher. Career: 13.1% BB rate and HR every 22 at-bats.

 

Three I’ll Let Pass Reason
Victor Martinez I would just rather wait for Napoli than reach for Martinez once the catcher run starts.
Jorge Posada The hit tool is fading as is his health. Plus Yankee fans love to draft him. They can have him.
Miguel Olivo Poor on-base skills, horrible park. I’ll pass completely on him.

 

Top 3 Rookie C Reason
J.P. Arencibia Could hit 25+ homers this year.
Hank Conger His bat can play now, his glove needs work. Should get bulk of at-bats with Angels.
Jesus Montero Posada and Russell Martin are the only things holding him back. He should get at-bats at catcher and DH by May.

-Jonathan C. Mitchell can be found writing about the Tampa Bay Rays at his other site Figure Filbert and on twitter at @FigureFilbert

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,664 other followers