MLB Dirt

This analysis is a little late as the trade took place almost two weeks ago but after reading a lot of articles that other people have written, I’ve looked at the trade a little different. In this article I’m really just going to focus on the Michael Pineda, and Jesus Montero parts of the trade and not the Jose Campos and Hector Noesi pieces. This was a rare trade as we usually do not see teams trade 22 year old phenoms to each other like the Yankees and Mariners did.

The Mariners had a chance to land Jesus Montero in a potential trade for Cliff Lee back in 2010. The deal was very very close to happening but it fell through and Cliff Lee ended up being dealt to the Rangers for a package around Justin Smoak. Well Smoak hasn’t quite lived up to the expectations in the eyes of many Mariners fans and people have gotten impatient. After trading Pineda for Montero, I have read people say that they wished the Mariners would have just traded for Montero in the first place back in 2010 and Pineda would have never been traded. People have called the trade for Montero a mulligan for Jack Zdurincik, almost like a re-do of the Cliff Lee deal. People think they should have made only one trade for a young bat and if the Mariners would have made the “right move” back in 2010, Pineda would have not had to been traded. Instead of looking at it like the Mariners should have just traded for Montero back in 2010, I look at it like the Mariners now have both Smoak AND Montero.
(more…)

Filed under: Digging Deep - Analysis | Tagged: Aaron Laffey, Blake Beavan, Cliff Lee, Hector Noesi, Jesus Montero, John Jaso, Jose Campos, Josh Lueke, Matt Lawson, Michael Pineda, New York Yankees, Seattle Mariners, Trades | 2 Comments »